Father Scott: MLB postseason announcing problem solver

Father Scott

I’m not going to link to anything or post pictures or be funny. I just have a quick idea to float out there, and then I’ll leave you alone.

There’s plenty of complaining about announcing and announcers and it gets old to read about, but I actually think for the most part their problems are understandable. They’re often hired based on name recognition rather than skill, so you end up with the Joe Morgans and Emmitt Smiths of the world who make up words or make assumptions about things and basically add no value to a broadcast. And then when you get to the playoffs, networks choose their “best” announcers regardless of how much of a sport they have watched that year, or who they have focused on. If Tim McCarver has watched 75 Cardinals games this year, it doesn’t mean that he has anything insightful to add to a Phillies/Dodgers tilt, which is why he spends the whole time complaining about Manny Ramirez.

The MLB playoffs have been full of inanity. Buck Martinez, who drives me crazy because of the way he says Ortiz, and also because he sounds like the slimy senator in the Godfather, made a comment last night during the Rays/Red Sox broadcast along the lines of the fact that most Red Sox fans may not know who Matt Garza is, or that he’s capable of dominating. News flash: The Rays were the best team in our division, we faced them like 97 times this regular season. We know who Matt Garza is.

But I guess this isn’t entirely Buck Martinez’s fault. How is he to know what Red Sox fans do or do not know? It’s true that most baseball fans might be shaky on the guy, so I guess it’s plausible for him to make the next step in assumptions. And no matter how much research he does, you can’t really understand a team or its fan base by cramming for a week. You have to live through the ups and downs and understand the team’s problems and strengths based on something other than whatever grabs the national headlines.

So his problem isn’t a lack of baseball knowledge, it’s (well, in addition to being annoying) that he doesn’t know who these teams are particularly well (at least compared to every other team), nor does he know the fanbases.

Well, you know who does? The teams’ regular color announcers. So, here’s a solution to make your broadcasts more enjoyable, TBS: Even if you want to force some boring announcer like Chip Caray down our throats (or Joe Buck, Fox), fill your three-man booth with a color announcer for each team.

Grab Remy, or if he doesn’t want to do it, grab a radio guy. And then add whatever two-bit lounge singer the Rays employ to do their games. Then when Chip says something general like “this isn’t the Josh Beckett we’ve grown accustomed to seeing,” Remy could pipe in that this is what we’ve seen all year, so it’s not that much of a surprise, you ridiculous douche.



Filed under media, sports

6 responses to “Father Scott: MLB postseason announcing problem solver

  1. I’m guessing the major issue with this would be contractual — i.e. non-compete clauses. But otherwise it’s a good idea. I like the idea of having Remy in the booth with the national guys during the Fenway games and then some Rays guy — probably Gomer Pyle or Jerry Seinfeld’s dad — in the booth for the Tropicana games.

  2. Fallen Angel

    DAMNIT PEOPLE. It’s Dewayne Staats, Joe Magrane, and Todd Kalas. But you pink-hatters wouldn’t know these things.

  3. Oh right, I forgot you were still pretending to be a Rays fan.

  4. TV execs seem to be enamored of three-man booths, which is why I suggested having both color guys. That way they can chime in on whenever someone from their team does something. But I’m always a fan of just two guys in the booth.

    I was thinking the same thing, but Orsillo did some first round games. I’m sure it would be fine contractually if they gave a little press to the team’s networks…as long as there were a couple of references to NESN, it could only be positive for Remy to be there.

  5. Colin

    Remy used to do color for Fox Saturday games a few years ago, so I don’t think there’s anything contractually prohibiting him or other announcers from doing national broadcasts.

    But there should be a rule prohibiting Cal Ripken, Jr. from ever getting anywhere near a microphone.

  6. I think they should have Emmit Smith do baseball. Honestly that would be the funniest possible thing in the entire universe.

    “What happened was that the strennf of the Red Sox just got debacled.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s